“Terrible how terribly good intentions turn out almost every time.”
Matthew is a Christian missionary trying to teach the scripture to the community's children. Despite his good intentions, his words unintentionally offend and disturb the community of Apple Island. The statement explores the theme of good intentions gone awry as the characters grapple with their beliefs and prejudices. In the case of Matthew Diamond, he genuinely wants to inspire the islanders about the unity of humanity drawing from the story of Noah's sons. However, his well-intentioned words have a negative impact on the community as it erases the people’s way of life. Hence, it demonstrates the complexities of human interactions and the difficulty in communicating one's beliefs.
“Lawyers are filing documents. Judges are signing orders. Scientist and doctors are collating data. Pharaoh’s heart is as hard as ever.”
The quote reflects the bureaucracy, authority, and unyielding nature of those in power. It alludes to the unjust systems that affect the lives of the characters—particularly the decisions surrounding Ethan's future. Matthew struggles with the decision to persuade Eha Honey to send his son to Massachusetts to study painting. He is aware of the societal norms that dictate how people with mixed-race heritage are perceived. Therefore, he realizes that the power structures and legal systems can be unforgiving to them. Esther Honey, on the other hand, understands the challenges her family faces due to their mixed-race heritage. Her silence during the discussion about Ethan's future reflects her recognition of the broader systemic issues.
“Wicked shepherds! Burn me at the stake and hang me from a tree. Clap me in the stocks; send me down the mine; set me in the burning fields. But I am queer.”
Zachary utters his sense of defiance, self-acceptance, and pride in his identity and difference. He recognizes the discrimination that different individuals face in society, which is represented by the references to burning at the stake and hanging from a tree. Zachary lives in a tree, which is a highly unconventional choice for a dwelling. His decision to live in nature outside of traditional housing structures highlights his alternative lifestyle. Furthermore, the island is home to various family structures including the eccentric family bonds formed between the characters. The statement is a commentary on the judgment coming from the outside world that believes in eugenics.
