The Joy Luck Club Lesson Plan

Ying-ying tells Lena that if she does not eat, she will marry a bad man. Does Lena marry a bad man?

Some students may argue that Harold is not a bad man. Lena contributed to the foundation of their relationship by agreeing to pay half or more of lunches and dinner. She started the trend of paying more than her share; Harold did not ask her to. This does not make Harold a bad man. Other students may argue that Harold takes advantage of Lena. He makes seven times what she makes, and she is the reason for his success. These students may argue that Harold is not a good man because he does not fully support and honor Lena. He also does not seem to understand her unhappiness,...