Essay Questions

Discuss the role of leadership and teamwork in the survival and rescue of the trapped miners.

Leadership and teamwork were crucial elements in the survival of the miners and the success of their rescue. Luis Urzua's immediate decision to organize rationing and maintain a semblance of normality provided the leadership needed for survival. Similarly, the miners' collective will to survive and their collaboration on tasks needed to stay alive represented teamwork at its finest. Above ground, Laurence Golborne's leadership in coordinating the rescue efforts, alongside the teamwork of the international experts, demonstrated the effectiveness of coordinated action in overcoming seemingly insurmountable challenges.

How does Trapped portray the theme of hope in the face of adversity?

Trapped presents hope as a crucial survival tool in dire circumstances. The miners maintain hope by staying organized, sending video messages to the surface, and maintaining faith in their eventual rescue. Above ground, the miners' families' establishment of "Camp Hope" is a testament to the enduring hope and solidarity shown by the community. Additionally, the rescue capsule named "Phoenix," the symbol of rebirth from the ashes, further emphasizes the theme of hope and renewal.

How does Marc Aronson use Trapped to comment on the values and responsibilities of society, particularly in relation to the mining industry?

Aronson uses the dramatic tale of the trapped miners to highlight the shortcomings of the mining industry and the broader society that tolerates such risks for the sake of economic gain. Aronson underscores the need for stricter regulations and greater responsibility within the industry through a detailed account of the perilous conditions in the San José Mine and the negligence that led to the disaster. At the same time, the unprecedented global response to the crisis illustrates society's capacity for empathy and cooperation, suggesting a potential for positive change.