Answer
The answer is $-16$.
Work Step by Step
To evaluate, substitute the given value of the variable in the expression, then perform the operation:
\begin{align}
9 - y^2 &= 9 - (-5)^2 &&\text{Substitute} \\
&= 9 - (25) &&\text{Square the number} \\
&= \color{red} {-16} &&\text{Evaluate}
\end{align}